Data from a qualitative study on collaboration in science

Michał Bojanowski (Kozminski Univeristy), Dominika Czerniawska (University of Manchester and University of Warsaw), Wojciech Fenrich (University of Warsaw)

Authors thank (Polish) National Science Centre for support through SONATA grant 2012/07/D/HS6/01971 for the project Dynamics of Competition and Collaboration in Science: Individual Strategies, Collaboration Networks, and Organizational Hierarchies (http://recon.icm.edu.pl).

---

This is a dataset built from a qualitative study of 40 Individual in-Depth Interviews (IDI) conducted in the period April-August of 2016 as a part of the RECON project on collaboration in Polish science. This repository is an R package, but the data is also stored in portable CSV format so that it can be used with any other analytical software.

Data collection

Data consists of 40 individual in-depth interviews conducted between April and August 2016 by two interviewers. The interviewees mentioned 333 collaborators in total. The sample consists of 20 female and 20 male scientists from six Polish cities. Respondents represented a broad range of disciplines: natural sciences, social sciences, life sciences, the humanities, engineering, and technology on different levels of career from PhD candidates to professors.

Each interview consisted of several parts two of which are of relevance here:

1. Respondents were asked to name up to 10 important collaborators during last 5 years. Each collaborator was discussed separately resulting with information about gender, scientific degree, nationality, and university department (if possible). Collected data is available in the nodes table described below.
2. During the interview a network of collaboration among collaborators mentioned in (1) was reconstructed using corkboard, pins, and rubber bands. The corkboards were photographed and later digitized into the collaboration table described below.
3. For each collaborator the respondents were asked about academically-relevant resources he/she contributed to the collaboration and what resources were contributed by the collaborator. Interviews were audio-recorded and later transcribed. The text of the transcripts was analyzed using QDA Miner Lite[1] in order to code resources engaged by respondents (the egos) and their collaborators (the alters) to every collaboration. The coding was performed by two persons. Random sample of the interviews was double-checked by different researchers to ensure reliability. The data is available in table resources and described in detail below.

While collaboration networks assembled from part (2) include alter-alter ties, the data on resources is available only for ego-alter dyads.

Data structure

The data is contained in three tables as shown in the diagram below:

In all tables the NA symbol (Not Available) is used to encode missing information.

Node data

The nodes table has 374 rows and the following 7 columns:

• id_interview – Unique interview identification number
• id_node – Node number unique within each interview. Value 0 corresponds to the respondent (the ego)
• is_ego – A binary variable which is equal to 1 for the respondents (the egos) and 0 otherwise.
• is_polish – A binary variable which is equal to 1 if the researcher is affiliated with a Polish academic institution and 0 otherwise.
• department – A numeric variable providing information whether two persons are affiliated with the same department at the same academic institution. Two researchers (i) and (j) mentioned in the same interview are affiliated with the same department if the have valid values on variable department and these values are equal.
• scidegree – Character variable encoding scientific degree. Values are "mgr"=MA, "dr"=PhD, "drhab"=habilitated PhD, and "prof"=full professor.
• female – Binary variable which is equal to 1 if the researcher is female and 0 for males.

Collaboration networks

The collaboration table has 1732 rows and the following 3 columns:

• id_interview – Unique interview identification number
• from and to – Node numbers referencing id_node column from the nodes table. As id_node in table nodes the values are unique within each interview. Pair of researchers declared as collaborators. For example a row with id_interview=2, from=1, and to=2 indicates that in the interview 2 nodes 1 and 2 where mentioned by the respondent as collaborators.

Resource “flow” networks

The resources table has 1761 rows and the following 4 columns:

• id_interview – Unique interview identification number.
• from and two – Node numbers referencing id_node column from the nodes table. As id_node in table nodes the values are unique within each interview.
• code – Character variable indicating what type of resource was declared to flow from researcher from to researcher to from interview id_interview.

Possible values for variable code are:

code
career_development
conceptualization
contacts_in_academia
data_analysis
data_curation
data_or_other_sources
drafting
equipment
formal_administration
funding_acqusition
investigation
knowledge_other
methodology
motivation
non_academic_contacts
other_charactersitics
other_input
prestige
professional_achievements_formal
project_administration
proofreading
prototype_construction
software_creation
supervision_in
traits_of_character

Example

Below are example data and plots from interview 2.

Node data:

nodes %>%
  filter(id_interview == 2) %>%
  knitr::kable()

id_interview	id_node	is_ego	is_polish	department	scidegree	female
2	0	1	1	1	dr	0
2	1	0	1	2	dr	0
2	2	0	1	3	dr	1
2	3	0	1	3	dr	1
2	4	0	1	2	dr	1
2	5	0	1	NA	dr	1
2	6	0	0	NA	prof	0
2	7	0	1	NA	NA	NA

Collaboration network:

g <- collaboration %>%
  filter(id_interview == 3) %>%
  select(-id_interview) %>%
  igraph::graph_from_data_frame(directed=FALSE) %>%
  simplify()

xy <- graphlayouts::layout_with_stress(g)

plot(
  g,
  layout=xy,
  vertex.color = "white",
  edge.color = "black",
  vertex.label.color = "black"
)

Resource flows:

edb <- resources %>%
  filter(id_interview==3) %>%
  select(-id_interview) %>%
  arrange(from, to)
rg <- graph_from_data_frame(edb)
rnames <- sort(unique(E(rg)$code))
layout(matrix(1:16, 4, 4))
for(r in rnames) {
  rgs <- delete.edges(rg, E(rg)[code != r])
  opar <- par(mar=c(0,0,1,0))
  plot(
    simplify(rgs), 
    layout=xy,
    vertex.color = "white",
    edge.color = "black",
    vertex.label.color = "black",
    main = r
  )
  par(opar)
}
layout(1)

Download links

This is an R package, but you can download the files in CSV format using links below:

• Nodes and their attributes (CSV)
• Collaboration ego-networks edgelist (CSV)
• Resource contributions in ego-networks (CSV)

Installation

This is an R package so you can install it directly from GitHub using:

remotes::install_github("recon-icm/reconqdata")

Acknowledgements

License

MIT license, see file LICENSE.md.

Citing

TBA. Please contact the authors for now.

1. A product of Provalis Research, see https://provalisresearch.com/products/qualitative-data-analysis-software/ .