num.lean

/-
Copyright (c) 2014 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved.
Released under Apache 2.0 license as described in the file LICENSE.
Author: Leonardo de Moura
-/
import data.bool tools.helper_tactics
open bool eq.ops decidable helper_tactics

namespace pos_num
  theorem succ_not_is_one (a : pos_num) : is_one (succ a) = ff :=
  pos_num.induction_on a rfl (take n iH, rfl) (take n iH, rfl)

  theorem succ_one                : succ one = bit0 one
  theorem succ_bit1 (a : pos_num) : succ (bit1 a) = bit0 (succ a)
  theorem succ_bit0 (a : pos_num) : succ (bit0 a) = bit1 a

  theorem ne_of_bit0_ne_bit0 {a b : pos_num} (H₁ : bit0 a ≠ bit0 b) : a ≠ b :=
  suppose a = b,
  absurd rfl (this ▸ H₁)

  theorem ne_of_bit1_ne_bit1 {a b : pos_num} (H₁ : bit1 a ≠ bit1 b) : a ≠ b :=
  suppose a = b,
  absurd rfl (this ▸ H₁)

  theorem pred_succ : ∀ (a : pos_num), pred (succ a) = a
  | one      := rfl
  | (bit0 a) := by rewrite succ_bit0
  | (bit1 a) :=
      calc
        pred (succ (bit1 a)) = cond (is_one (succ a)) one (bit1 (pred (succ a))) : rfl
                       ...   = cond ff one (bit1 (pred (succ a)))                : succ_not_is_one
                       ...   = bit1 (pred (succ a))                              : rfl
                       ...   = bit1 a                                            : pred_succ a

  section
  variables (a b : pos_num)

  theorem one_add_one     : one + one = bit0 one
  theorem one_add_bit0    : one + (bit0 a) = bit1 a
  theorem one_add_bit1    : one + (bit1 a) = succ (bit1 a)
  theorem bit0_add_one    : (bit0 a) + one = bit1 a
  theorem bit1_add_one    : (bit1 a) + one = succ (bit1 a)
  theorem bit0_add_bit0   : (bit0 a) + (bit0 b) = bit0 (a + b)
  theorem bit0_add_bit1   : (bit0 a) + (bit1 b) = bit1 (a + b)
  theorem bit1_add_bit0   : (bit1 a) + (bit0 b) = bit1 (a + b)
  theorem bit1_add_bit1   : (bit1 a) + (bit1 b) = succ (bit1 (a + b))
  theorem one_mul         : one * a = a
  end

  theorem mul_one         : ∀ a, a * one = a
  | one      := rfl
  | (bit1 n) :=
      calc bit1 n * one = bit0 (n * one) + one : rfl
                   ...  = bit0 n + one         : mul_one n
                   ...  = bit1 n               : bit0_add_one
  | (bit0 n) :=
      calc bit0 n * one = bit0 (n * one)       : rfl
                    ... = bit0 n               : mul_one n

  theorem decidable_eq [instance] : ∀ (a b : pos_num), decidable (a = b)
  | one      one      := inl rfl
  | one      (bit0 b) := inr (by contradiction)
  | one      (bit1 b) := inr (by contradiction)
  | (bit0 a) one      := inr (by contradiction)
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) :=
    match decidable_eq a b with
    | inl H₁  := inl (by rewrite H₁)
    | inr H₁  := inr (by intro H; injection H; contradiction)
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) := inr (by contradiction)
  | (bit1 a) one      := inr (by contradiction)
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) := inr (by contradiction)
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) :=
    match decidable_eq a b with
    | inl H₁  := inl (by rewrite H₁)
    | inr H₁  := inr (by intro H; injection H; contradiction)
    end

  local notation a < b         := (lt a b = tt)
  local notation a ` ≮ `:50 b:50 := (lt a b = ff)

  theorem lt_one_right_eq_ff : ∀ a : pos_num, a ≮ one
  | one      := rfl
  | (bit0 a) := rfl
  | (bit1 a) := rfl

  theorem lt_one_succ_eq_tt : ∀ a : pos_num, one < succ a
  | one      := rfl
  | (bit0 a) := rfl
  | (bit1 a) := rfl

  theorem lt_of_lt_bit0_bit0 {a b : pos_num} (H : bit0 a < bit0 b) : a < b := H
  theorem lt_of_lt_bit0_bit1 {a b : pos_num} (H : bit1 a < bit0 b) : a < b := H
  theorem lt_of_lt_bit1_bit1 {a b : pos_num} (H : bit1 a < bit1 b) : a < b := H
  theorem lt_of_lt_bit1_bit0 {a b : pos_num} (H : bit0 a < bit1 b) : a < succ b := H

  theorem lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt (a b : pos_num) : lt (bit0 a) (bit0 b) = lt a b :=
  rfl

  theorem lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt (a b : pos_num) : lt (bit1 a) (bit1 b) = lt a b :=
  rfl

  theorem lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt (a b : pos_num) : lt (bit1 a) (bit0 b) = lt a b :=
  rfl

  theorem lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ (a b : pos_num) : lt (bit0 a) (bit1 b) = lt a (succ b) :=
  rfl

  theorem lt_irrefl : ∀ (a : pos_num), a ≮ a
  | one      := rfl
  | (bit0 a) :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt, apply lt_irrefl
    end
  | (bit1 a) :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt, apply lt_irrefl
    end

  theorem ne_of_lt_eq_tt : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, a < b → a = b → false
  | one      ⌞one⌟      H₁ (eq.refl one)      := absurd H₁ ff_ne_tt
  | (bit0 a) ⌞(bit0 a)⌟ H₁ (eq.refl (bit0 a)) :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₁,
      apply ne_of_lt_eq_tt H₁ (eq.refl a)
    end
  | (bit1 a) ⌞(bit1 a)⌟ H₁ (eq.refl (bit1 a)) :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H₁,
      apply ne_of_lt_eq_tt H₁ (eq.refl a)
    end

  theorem lt_base : ∀ a : pos_num, a < succ a
  | one      := rfl
  | (bit0 a) :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit0, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ],
      apply lt_base
    end
  | (bit1 a) :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt],
      apply lt_base
    end

  theorem lt_step : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, a < b → a < succ b
  | one      one      H := rfl
  | one      (bit0 b) H := rfl
  | one      (bit1 b) H := rfl
  | (bit0 a) one      H := absurd H ff_ne_tt
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit0, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H],
      apply lt_step H
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H],
      exact H
    end
  | (bit1 a) one      H := absurd H ff_ne_tt
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit0, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H],
      exact H
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H],
      apply lt_step H
    end

  theorem lt_of_lt_succ_succ : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, succ a < succ b → a < b
  | one      one      H := absurd H ff_ne_tt
  | one      (bit0 b) H := rfl
  | one      (bit1 b) H := rfl
  | (bit0 a) one      H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit0 at H, succ_one at H, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H],
      apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff a) H
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) H := by exact H
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) H := by exact H
  | (bit1 a) one      H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1 at H, succ_one at H, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H],
      apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff (succ a)) H
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1 at H, succ_bit0 at H, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H],
      rewrite lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt,
      apply lt_of_lt_succ_succ H
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt, *succ_bit1 at H, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H],
      apply lt_of_lt_succ_succ H
    end

  theorem lt_succ_succ : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, a < b → succ a < succ b
  | one      one      H := absurd H ff_ne_tt
  | one      (bit0 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit0, succ_one, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ],
      apply lt_one_succ_eq_tt
    end
  | one      (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_one, succ_bit1, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt],
      apply lt_one_succ_eq_tt
    end
  | (bit0 a) one      H := absurd H ff_ne_tt
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) H := by exact H
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) H := by exact H
  | (bit1 a) one      H := absurd H ff_ne_tt
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1, succ_bit0, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H],
      apply lt_succ_succ H
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H, *succ_bit1, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt],
      apply lt_succ_succ H
    end

  theorem lt_of_lt_succ : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, succ a < b → a < b
  | one      one      H := absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt !lt_one_right_eq_ff H
  | one      (bit0 b) H := rfl
  | one      (bit1 b) H := rfl
  | (bit0 a) one      H := absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt !lt_one_right_eq_ff H
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) H := by exact H
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit0 at H, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ],
      apply lt_step H
    end
  | (bit1 a) one      H := absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt !lt_one_right_eq_ff H
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt, succ_bit1 at H, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H],
      apply lt_of_lt_succ H
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1 at H, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt],
      apply lt_of_lt_succ_succ H
    end

  theorem lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, a < succ b → a ≠ b → a < b
  | one      one      H₁ H₂ := absurd rfl H₂
  | one      (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ := rfl
  | one      (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ := rfl
  | (bit0 a) one      H₁ H₂ :=
  begin
    rewrite [succ_one at H₁, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₁],
    apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff _) H₁
  end
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt, succ_bit0 at H₁, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H₁],
      apply lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne H₁ (ne_of_bit0_ne_bit0 H₂)
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1 at H₁, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₁, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ],
      exact H₁
    end
  | (bit1 a) one      H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_one at H₁, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H₁],
      apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff _) H₁
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit0 at H₁, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H₁, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt],
      exact H₁
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [succ_bit1 at H₁, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H₁, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt],
      apply lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne H₁ (ne_of_bit1_ne_bit1 H₂)
    end

  theorem lt_trans : ∀ {a b c : pos_num}, a < b → b < c → a < c
  | one      b        (bit0 c) H₁ H₂ := rfl
  | one      b        (bit1 c) H₁ H₂ := rfl
  | a        (bit0 b) one      H₁ H₂ := absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff _) H₂
  | a        (bit1 b) one      H₁ H₂ := absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff _) H₂
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) (bit0 c) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at *, apply lt_trans H₁ H₂
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) (bit1 c) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at *, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₁],
      apply lt_trans H₁ H₂
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) (bit0 c) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H₁, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H₂, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt],
      apply @by_cases (a = b),
      begin
         intro H, rewrite -H at H₂, exact H₂
      end,
      begin
        intro H,
        apply lt_trans (lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne H₁ H) H₂
      end
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) (bit1 c) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at *, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H₂],
      apply lt_trans H₁ (lt_succ_succ H₂)
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) (bit0 c) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₂, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at *],
      apply lt_trans H₁ H₂
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) (bit1 c) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H₁, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H₂, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt],
      apply @by_cases (b = c),
      begin
        intro H, rewrite H at H₁, exact H₁
      end,
      begin
        intro H,
        apply lt_trans H₁ (lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne H₂ H)
      end
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) (bit0 c) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H₁, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H₂, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt],
      apply lt_trans H₁ H₂
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) (bit1 c) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at *,
      apply lt_trans H₁ H₂
    end

  theorem lt_antisymm : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, a < b → b ≮ a
  | one      one      H := rfl
  | one      (bit0 b) H := rfl
  | one      (bit1 b) H := rfl
  | (bit0 a) one      H := absurd H ff_ne_tt
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at *,
      apply lt_antisymm H
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt,
      rewrite lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H,
      have H₁ : succ b ≮ a, from lt_antisymm H,
      apply eq_ff_of_ne_tt,
        intro H₂,
        apply @by_cases (succ b = a),
        show succ b = a → false,
        begin
          intro Hp,
          rewrite -Hp at H,
          apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_irrefl (succ b)) H
        end,
        show succ b ≠ a → false,
        begin
          intro Hn,
          have H₃ : succ b < succ a, from lt_succ_succ H₂,
          have H₄ : succ b < a, from lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne H₃ Hn,
          apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt H₁ H₄
        end,
    end
  | (bit1 a) one      H := absurd H ff_ne_tt
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ,
      rewrite lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H,
      have H₁ : lt b a = ff, from lt_antisymm H,
      apply eq_ff_of_ne_tt,
        intro H₂,
        apply @by_cases (b = a),
        show b = a → false,
        begin
          intro Hp,
          rewrite -Hp at H,
          apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_irrefl b) H
        end,
        show b ≠ a → false,
        begin
          intro Hn,
          have H₃ : b < a, from lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne H₂ Hn,
          apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt H₁ H₃
        end,
      end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) H :=
    begin
      rewrite lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at *,
      apply lt_antisymm H
    end

  local notation a ≤ b := (le a b = tt)

  theorem le_refl : ∀ a : pos_num, a ≤ a :=
  lt_base

  theorem le_eq_lt_succ {a b : pos_num} : le a b = lt a (succ b) :=
  rfl

  theorem not_lt_of_le : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, a ≤ b → b < a → false
  | one      one      H₁ H₂ := absurd H₂ ff_ne_tt
  | one      (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ := absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff _) H₂
  | one      (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ := absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff _) H₂
  | (bit0 a) one      H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at H₁, succ_one at H₁, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₁],
      apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff _) H₁
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at H₁, succ_bit0 at H₁, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H₁],
      rewrite [lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₂],
      apply not_lt_of_le H₁ H₂
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at H₁, succ_bit1 at H₁, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₁],
      rewrite [lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H₂],
      apply not_lt_of_le H₁ H₂
    end
  | (bit1 a) one      H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at H₁, succ_one at H₁, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H₁],
      apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff _) H₁
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at H₁, succ_bit0 at H₁, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H₁],
      rewrite lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at H₂,
      have H₃ : a < succ b, from lt_step H₁,
      apply @by_cases (b = a),
      begin
        intro Hba, rewrite -Hba at H₁,
        apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_irrefl b) H₁
      end,
      begin
        intro Hnba,
        have H₄ : b < a, from lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne H₂ Hnba,
        apply not_lt_of_le H₃ H₄
      end
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at H₁, succ_bit1 at H₁, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at H₁],
      rewrite [lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H₂],
      apply not_lt_of_le H₁ H₂
    end

  theorem le_antisymm : ∀ {a b : pos_num}, a ≤ b → b ≤ a → a = b
  | one      one      H₁ H₂ := rfl
  | one      (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    by apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff b) H₂
  | one      (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    by apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff b) H₂
  | (bit0 a) one      H₁ H₂ :=
    by apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff a) H₁
  | (bit0 a) (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at *, succ_bit0 at *, lt_bit0_bit1_eq_lt_succ at *],
      have H : a = b, from le_antisymm H₁ H₂,
      rewrite H
    end
  | (bit0 a) (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at *, succ_bit1 at H₁, succ_bit0 at H₂],
      rewrite [lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₁, lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H₂],
      apply false.rec _ (not_lt_of_le H₁ H₂)
    end
  | (bit1 a) one      H₁ H₂ :=
    by apply absurd_of_eq_ff_of_eq_tt (lt_one_right_eq_ff a) H₁
  | (bit1 a) (bit0 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at *, succ_bit0 at H₁, succ_bit1 at H₂],
      rewrite [lt_bit1_bit1_eq_lt at H₁, lt_bit0_bit0_eq_lt at H₂],
      apply false.rec _ (not_lt_of_le H₂ H₁)
    end
  | (bit1 a) (bit1 b) H₁ H₂ :=
    begin
      rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at *, succ_bit1 at *, lt_bit1_bit0_eq_lt at *],
      have H : a = b, from le_antisymm H₁ H₂,
      rewrite H
    end

  theorem le_trans {a b c : pos_num} : a ≤ b → b ≤ c → a ≤ c :=
  begin
    intro H₁ H₂,
    rewrite [le_eq_lt_succ at *],
    apply @by_cases (a = b),
    begin
      intro Hab, rewrite Hab, exact H₂
    end,
    begin
      intro Hnab,
      have Haltb : a < b, from lt_of_lt_succ_of_ne H₁ Hnab,
      apply lt_trans Haltb H₂
    end,
  end

end pos_num

namespace num
  open pos_num

  theorem decidable_eq [instance] : ∀ (a b : num), decidable (a = b)
  | zero zero       := inl rfl
  | zero (pos b)    := inr (by contradiction)
  | (pos a) zero    := inr (by contradiction)
  | (pos a) (pos b) :=
    if H : a = b then inl (by rewrite H) else inr (suppose pos a = pos b, begin injection this, contradiction end)
end num